Vitamin C content and amino acid identification in
carbonated beverage with kiwifruit (Actinidia
deliciosa), ACHOTILLO (Nephelium lappaceum) and
MORINGA (Moringa oleifera).
Contenido de vitamina c e identificación de aminoácidos en
bebida carbonatada con kiwi (Actinidia deliciosa)
ACHOTILLO (Nephelium lappaceum) y MORINGA (Moringa
oleífera)
Jonathan Armijos-Martinez
1
Carolina Paz-Yépez
2
Abstract: The carbonated beverage industries are constantly
changing due to the growing demand for the inclusion of natural
products. Consumers are looking for beverages that are sources of
nutrients with low caloric content. In this context, an experimental
study was carried out with the main objective of determining the
vitamin C and amino acid content in a carbonated beverage made
from kiwi, achotillo and moringa. Sensory, physicochemical and
microbiological analyses were also performed on the best treatment
selected by a sensory panel of 30 untrained judges. The treatment that
received the best sensory evaluation was the one formulated with 20%
kiwifruit, 70% achotillo and 0.1% moringa. This treatment presented
a vitamin C content of 212.24 mg/kg and total amino acids of 2.29
w/w. The physicochemical results obtained were a pH of 4.3, a citric
acid content of 0.27% and total solids of 6.2 °Brix. The
microbiological results showed an absence of mesophilic aerobes, less
than 2 NPM/ml of total coliforms and less than 10 up/cm3 of molds
and yeasts. These values are within the range established by INEN
1101:2008 for carbonated beverages. Analyses of the proposed
beverage show that the product has a vitamin C content that exceeds
10% of the recommended daily intake, in addition to providing amino
acids. This makes the beverage an interesting option compared to
current carbonated beverages that do not include natural ingredients.
Keywords: achotillo, amino acids, kiwifruit, moringa, vitamin C
Published
Instituto Tecnológico Superior Edwards
Deming. Quito Ecuador
Periodicity
April - June
Dates of receipt
Received: January 09, 2023
Approved: March 12, 2023
http://centrosuragraria.com/index.php/revista
vol. 2. Num. 18. 2023.
pp. 34-53
Correspondence author
menriquez@uea.edu.ec
Creative Commons License
Creative Commons License, Attribution-
NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0
International.https://creativecommons.org/lice
nses/by-nc-sa/4.0/deed.es
1 Eng. Dr. Jacobo Bucaram Ortiz Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, Agrarian University of Ecuador. Guayaquil-Ecuador,
jarmijos@uagraria.edu.ec, https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0997-1893
2 Jacobo Bucaram Ortiz, PhD Research Institute, Agrarian University of Ecuador. Guayaquil-Ecuador, cpaz@uagraria.edu.ec,
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9547-2817
July - September vol. 1. Num. 18 - 2023
35
Resumen: Las industrias dedicadas a la elaboración de bebidas
carbonatadas cambian constantemente debido a la creciente demanda
de inclusión de productos naturales. Los consumidores buscan
bebidas que sean fuentes de nutrientes con un bajo contenido calórico.
En este contexto, se llevó a cabo un estudio experimental con el
objetivo principal de determinar el contenido de vitamina C y
aminoácidos en una bebida carbonatada de kiwi, achotillo y moringa.
Se realizaron también análisis sensoriales, fisicoquímico y
microbiológicos al mejor tratamiento seleccionado por un panel
sensorial conformado por 30 jueces no entrenados. El tratamiento que
recibió la mejor evaluación sensorial fue el que se formuló con un
20% de kiwi, un 70% de achotillo y un 0.1% de moringa. Este
tratamiento presentó un contenido de vitamina C de 212.24 mg/kg y
aminoácidos totales de 2.29 p/p. Los resultados fisicoquímicos
obtenidos fueron un pH de 4.3, un contenido de ácido cítrico del
0.27% y sólidos totales de 6.2 °Brix. En cuanto a los resultados
microbiológicos, se encontró ausencia de aerobios mesófilos, menos
de 2 NPM/ml de coliformes totales y menos de 10 up/cm3 de mohos
y levaduras. Estos valores se mantienen dentro del rango establecido
por la norma INEN 1101:2008 para bebidas carbonatadas. Los
análisis realizados a la bebida propuesta demuestran que el producto
tiene un contenido de vitamina C que supera el 10% de la ingesta
diaria recomendada, además de proporcionar aminoácidos. Esto
convierte a la bebida en una opción interesante en comparación con
las bebidas carbonatadas actuales que no incluyen ingredientes
naturales.
Palabras clave: achotillo, aminoácidos, kiwi, moringa, vitamina C
Introduction
In Ecuador, there are around 4,000 companies dedicated to the
production of beverages, including carbonated beverages, juices, tea,
energy drinks, water and dairy products. These beverage industries are
in a constant process of innovation with the purpose of applying the
appropriate techniques that guarantee the safety of the processes and
that in turn will help contribute to the generation of nutritional
beverages (Valverde, 2018).
Among the types of carbonated beverages are energy drinks, the energy
provided by these beverages is due to the high fructose content.
According to Maersk et al. (2012), fructose plays a very important role
in weight gain and consequently in the development of obesity. In
Ecuador, the per capita consumption of carbonated beverages is 50
l/year, due to the great demand for these beverages, there has been
interest in creating research to develop products of this type, but with
the purpose of containing and providing nutritional value, generating
Vitamin C content and amino acid identification in carbonated beverage with kiwifruit (Actinidia
deliciosa), ACHOTILLO (Nephelium lappaceum) and MORINGA (Moringa oleifera)
36
more alternatives when consuming nutrients from a refreshing source
(Gaona-Gonzeaga et al., 2019)..
Nowadays, people try to get food products, which contain a higher
nutritional contribution and can also generate health benefits, therefore,
there has been an increased interest in the study of beverages with these
characteristics, which has contributed to the development of products
made from the mixture of vegetable species and fruit (Llanes, 2015).
Nutrients are essential for the body because they enable the
development, maintenance and functioning of our body, so by
consuming carbonated beverages we are not giving any nutritional
contribution that can benefit human health (FAO, 2019). However, this
situation can be addressed with proposals for beverages in this category
that incorporate ingredients with bioactive compounds of nutritional
interest in their formulation.
The kiwi is a fruit that has a high nutritional value, it contains vitamin
C and vitamin E, with a higher contribution of nutrients compared to
other commonly consumed fruits, vitamin C has beneficial effects on
the immune system and antioxidant power, helps in the gastrointestinal
function and the respiratory system. (Carr and Frei, 1999).
Achotillo is an exotic tropical fruit that grows in tropical or subtropical
climates. Its main component is fiber, which is resistant to digestion and
absorption in the small intestine. Among the vitamins it possesses is
vitamin C, which groups dehydroascorbic, isoascorbic and L-ascorbic
acids, which make up the active biological part that has protective
effects against various diseases such as cardiovascular diseases, it also
has phenolic compounds that help reduce the risk of diseases such as
diabetes (McEvily et al., 1992)..
Moringa is one of the fast growing plant species known as the "tree of
life" and this is due to its great nutritional contribution, moringa leaves
have a high protein content with all the essential amino acids, also, it
has a variety of vitamins such as A, B, C and E and a large number of
nutrients and micronutrients such as calcium, zinc, magnesium among
others... (Rubio-Sanz, 2020). (Rubio-Sanz, 2020)Amino acids are
essential for our organism, since they are the compounds in charge of
combining and forming the proteins that provide energy to our body.
(Solutions., 2021). Likewise, because the body does not produce
vitamin C, it needs to obtain it from the diet (Carr and Maggini, 2017).
Based on the above, the importance of generating alternatives to the
consumer with regard to innovative products that provide nutrients is of
July - September vol. 1. Num. 18 - 2023
37
greater interest every day. As well as in the proposal to generate a
positive change in the choice of beverages that denote a benefit.
Rodriguez (2020) determined the presence of antioxidants in a beverage
made with soy milk (Glycine max) and kiwi (Actinida deliciosa),
flavored with passion fruit. From this study it is highlighted that the best
sensorially qualified treatment of the soy beverage was the one
elaborated with 40 % soy, while, of the kiwi concentrations studied, the
treatment with the highest sensorial acceptance was the one containing
40 % kiwi.
Sanchinelli (2004) conducted an investigation to determine the protein
content, essential amino acids in leaves, flowers and stems of Moringa
oleifera, which is cultivated in Guatemala. The protein content in
Moringa oleifera was found to range from 1.30 to 4.62 %, with the
highest content in the leaves. The essential amino acid content was
found to range from 98 to 1384 mg/100 g and from 90 to 270 mg/100 g
in dehydrated and fresh leaves, respectively. In flowers the range was
from 23 to 122 mg/100 g and in stems from 11 to 37 mg/100 g. The
limiting amino acid in leaves was lysine; in flowers the limiting amino
acids were valine and methionine; and in stems the limiting amino acid
was valine.
Cedaro et al. (2015) presented a paper on the analysis of vitamin C in
soft drinks, the results of a survey carried out on 52 products that are
part of the usual offer of these beverages Obtained ascorbic acid levels
in a range from 0 to 82.36±4.84 mg/200mL, corresponding the highest
values to orange flavored products. This study determined the presence
of vitamin C and the amino acid profile in a carbonated beverage with
kiwi (Actinidia deliciosa), achotillo (Nephelium lappaceum) and
moringa (Moringa oleifera) that will provide a beverage with
nutritional appeal. The antioxidant properties of kiwi and achotillo,
together with the nutritional benefits such as the amino acids provided
by moringa, will be used to generate a new carbonated beverage that
not only provides the sensation of freshness, but is also potentially
beneficial to health.
Materials and methods
The present work proposed the study of the vitamin C content and
amino acid profile in a carbonated beverage composed of three
ingredients: kiwi, achotillo and moringa. The details of the proposed
formulation are presented in Table 1.
Vitamin C content and amino acid identification in carbonated beverage with kiwifruit (Actinidia
deliciosa), ACHOTILLO (Nephelium lappaceum) and MORINGA (Moringa oleifera)
38
Table 1. Percentages of ingredients used for the different treatments in
the formulation of the carbonated beverage.
Description of the percentages of ingredients for the different
treatments in the formulation of the carbonated beverage.
Armijos, 2022
From the results obtained, the beverage with the best score was selected.
The formulated beverage with the best sensory score had its vitamin C
content, amino acid profile, physical-chemical and microbiological
analysis determined.
Material resources
The raw materials (kiwi, achotillo, moringa, monkfruit, lemon, sodium
benzoate, carbon dioxide) used were obtained from local businesses.
Methods and techniques
Figure 1 shows the flow diagrams of the processes used to obtain the
beverage under study.
Sensory evaluation method
Ingredients
T1
T2
Actinidia
deliciosa (kiwi)
25%
20%
Nephelium
lappaceum
(Achotillo)
45%
50%
Moringa oleifera
0.1
%
0.1%
Monk fruit
0.25
%
0.25%
Water
29.04%
29.04%
CO
2
Sodium benzoate
Citric acid
0.5%
0.05%
0.06%
0.5%
0.05%
0.06%
July - September vol. 1. Num. 18 - 2023
39
For the sensory evaluation of the organoleptic characteristics (color,
odor and flavor), a panel composed of 30 untrained persons between 18
and 30 years of age was selected; each member of the panel received 3
containers, each containing a treatment to be evaluated. Subsequently,
they received an evaluation form where they recorded the data using a
5-point hedonic scale, where 5 is the highest score and 1 is the lowest
score.
The score of 5 had a category of "I like it very much", the score of 4
had a category of "I like it", the score of 3 had a category of "I neither
like nor dislike it", the score of 2 had a category of "I dislike it" and the
score of 1 had a category of "I dislike it very much". To evaluate the
vitamin C content, amino acid profile, physicochemical and
microbiological parameters of the best evaluated treatment, analyses
were performed in an accredited laboratory.
Physicochemical parameters
pH determination
For pH titration, the procedure detailed in INEN 1087 was followed.
Determination of carbon dioxide gas
For the determination of carbon dioxide gas, the procedure detailed in
INEN 1082 was followed.
Determination of Brix degrees
For the determination of Brix degrees, the procedure detailed in INEN
1083 was followed.
Acidity determination
For the determination of acidity, the procedure detailed in NTE INEN
1091 was followed.
Determination of vitamin C by HPLC
The sample chosen with the best score by the sensory panel had its
vitamin C content determined by HPLC.
Liquid chromatography (HPLC) is a technique used to separate the
components of a mixture. It consists of a non-polar stationary phase
(column) and a mobile phase. The stationary phase is silica that has
been treated with RMe
2
SiCl. The mobile phase acts as a sample carrier.
The sample in solution is injected into the mobile phase. The
components of the solution migrate according to the non-covalent
interactions of the compounds with the column. These chemical
interactions determine the separation of the contents of the sample. The
use of the different detectors will depend on the nature of the
compounds to be determined (Miranda and Martín, 2013).
C18 column and an RP-18 precolumn were used for the stationary
phase, and the mobile phase, sulfuric acid was used to reach pH 2.2.
Vitamin C content and amino acid identification in carbonated beverage with kiwifruit (Actinidia
deliciosa), ACHOTILLO (Nephelium lappaceum) and MORINGA (Moringa oleifera)
40
The flow rate was 0.4 mL/min, and the UVVIS detector at 225 nm.
(Fang, 2017).
Determination of amino acid profile by the Burbach Institute
Prederivatized (HPLC-FLD) method.
The sample chosen with the best score by the sensory panel had its
amino acid profile determined by the Burbach Institute Prederivatized
(HPLC-FLD) method (Castillo-Portela et al., 2011). (Castillo-Portela et
al., 2011)..
Microbiological analysis for mesophiles by BAM-FDA method
CAP#3
This method is based on the certainty that a vital microorganism present
in a food sample, when inoculated in a solid nutrient medium, will
reproduce forming a visible individual colony. To make colony
counting possible, decimal dilutions of the initial sample suspension are
made and the nutrient culture medium is inoculated. The inoculum is
incubated at 30°C for 72 hours and then the number of colonies formed
is counted. The count is used to calculate the amount of microorganisms
per gram or per cubic centimeter of food (INEN, 2006). (INEN, 2006).
The sample chosen with the best score by the sensory panel underwent
the respective microbiological analysis by the most probable number
method for the detection of mesophiles.
Multiple fermentation tube method for coliform analysis
The method is based on the detection of the most probable number
(MPN) by the tube dilution technique using the selective liquid medium
bile-lactose brilliant green broth or similar for the presumptive assay
and the tubes that present gas are plated on Eosin methylene blue agar
(E M B). The incubation temperature for the presumptive and
confirmatory assay is 30 +-1°C for refrigerated products and 35+-1°C
for products kept at room temperature. (INEN, 1990).
Analysis of molds and yeasts by the plate count method by deep
sowing
This method is based on the cultivation between 22ºC and 25ºC of the
propagating units of molds and yeasts, using the plate count technique
by deep sowing and a medium containing yeast extract, glucose and
mineral salts. (INEN, 2013).
Sensory evaluation method
A sensory panel of 30 untrained judges was selected for the analysis of
odor, color and flavor of the samples of each of the treatments under
July - September vol. 1. Num. 18 - 2023
41
study. A 5-point hedonic scale was used to measure the sensory
characteristics.
Statistical analysis
The information obtained at the end of the carbonated beverage
treatments for each of the sensory variables, using the 5-point scale
planned to be used, was statistically evaluated by analysis of variance
(ANOVA). In the case of obtaining significant differences, the Tukey
test was used as a test for comparison of means. These two statistical
tools were applied at 5% significance.
The analysis of variance model is detailed in Table 2.
Table 2. Analysis of variance for sensory variables
Sources of variation
Degrees of freedom
Total (n-1)
89
Treatments (t-1)
2
Repetitions (judges)(R-1)
29
Experimental error (t-1) (R-1)
58
Presentation of analysis of variance for sensory variables, Armijos,
2021
3. Result
Results of formulation selection of carbonated beverage
formulation made with kiwi achotillo and moringa from a sensory
panel.
Sensory tests were conducted to evaluate a carbonated kiwi, achotillo
and moringa beverage. Three treatments were established with different
proportions of kiwifruit and achotillo, while moringa, monkfruit, citric
acid and sodium benzoate were held constant in the three formulations.
The preparation of the beverage followed the process previously
detailed in Figure 1. 20 kg of kiwifruit and achotillo in good condition
and of acceptable quality were selected, based on their physiological
maturity index and sugar content (12ºBrix for kiwifruit and 17ºBrix for
achotillo). The fruits were washed with water and disinfected with 0.5%
lactic acid for 3 minutes. They were then peeled and the pulp was
weighed according to the proportions required for each formulation.
The pulps were liquefied to obtain the juice, which was then filtered to
separate solid residues.
Subsequently, the pulps were mixed and citric acid was added as a
stabilizer and sodium benzoate as a preservative. Pasteurization was
carried out at 70ºC for 30 minutes, followed by thermal shock in water
Vitamin C content and amino acid identification in carbonated beverage with kiwifruit (Actinidia
deliciosa), ACHOTILLO (Nephelium lappaceum) and MORINGA (Moringa oleifera)
42
and ice to rapidly reduce the temperature to 20ºC and ensure the
elimination of microorganisms. Water, non-caloric sweetener
(monkfruit) and moringa powder were added. The juice was cooled to
4ºC for one day and then carbonated by mixing with carbon dioxide.
Finally, it was packaged in amber glass bottles and stored at 4ºC.
Analysis of variance and tukey's test to the treatments evaluated by
the panelists.
The results obtained from the sensory tests of the treatments performed
on the panelists with their replicates were recorded in a Microsoft Excel
spreadsheet, and then exported to Infostat (2020), followed by an
analysis of variance using the Tukey test at 5% probability, which made
it possible to determine the significant difference between treatments
by checking the significance level (p-value).
As can be seen in Table 4, treatment 2 did not present a significant
difference with treatment 1 for the attributes of color and flavor, so
treatment 2 was chosen for having the highest mean, which was 3.73
for the attribute of color, while the mean for this same treatment in the
attribute of flavor was 3.60 and for the attribute of odor, treatment 2 had
a mean of 3.50, presenting a significant difference between treatments
1 and 3, which did not present a significant difference between them
with respect to the aforementioned attribute.
Table 3 shows the results of the sensory evaluation of the treatments.
Table 3. Sensory evaluation of the kiwi, achotillo and moringa
carbonated beverage treatments.
Means of sensory attributes in the proposed treatments of the
carbonated beverage.
Means with a letter in common are not significantly different (p>0.05).
Treatments Color Odor Flavor
Treatment 1 3.57
b
2.93
a
3.39
b
Treatment 2 3.73
b
3.50
b
3.60
b
Treatment 3 3.06
a
2.86
a
2.86
a
CV 27.91 37.89 35.92
July - September vol. 1. Num. 18 - 2023
43
Determination of the Vitamin C content and amino acid profile of
the carbonated beverage made with kiwi, achotillo and moringa
selected as the best scored from the sensory panel.
According to the analysis of the vitamin C content of the kiwi, achotillo
and moringa carbonated beverage corresponding to treatment 2,
selected as the one with the highest sensory acceptance, it registered a
vitamin C content of 212.39 mg/kg (21.24 mg/100g), highlighting that
the raw materials used for its preparation are a good source of this
vitamin.
Amino acid profile results of the best scoring treatment of the kiwi,
achotillo and moringa carbonated beverage.
Table 4 shows the values corresponding to the amino acid profile of
treatment 2 of the carbonated beverage selected as the best scored by
the sensory panel.
Table 4. Amino acid profile of carbonated beverages
Results of the amino acid profile of the carbonated beverage.
Evaluation of the physicochemical (acidity, ºbrix, pH, CO Volume
2
)
and microbiological (total& coliforms,& mesophilic& molds& and&
yeasts)& parameters of the kiwi (Actinidia deliciosa) achotillo
(Nephelium lappaceum) and moringa (Moringa oleifera) carbonated
Amino acids gAA/100g
Aspartic Acid 0.18
Glutamic Acid 0.35
Serine 0.12
Histidine 0.00
Threonine 0.12
Glycine 0.16
Arginine 0.12
Alanine 0.00
Tyrosine 0.72
Valine 0.09
Methionia 0.04
Phenyl alanine 0.12
Isoleucine 0.09
Leucine 0.13
Lysine 0.05
Total amino acids 2.29 w/w
Vitamin C content and amino acid identification in carbonated beverage with kiwifruit (Actinidia
deliciosa), ACHOTILLO (Nephelium lappaceum) and MORINGA (Moringa oleifera)
44
beverage according to the NTE INEN 1101:2008 Standard for
carbonated beverages for the treatment with the highest score in the
sensory panel.
Physicochemical results of the kiwi, achotillo and moringa
carbonated beverage.
The results of the physicochemical parameters for treatment 2 indicate
that they are within the ranges established by NTE INEN 1101:2008 for
carbonated beverages.
Table 5 presents the results obtained from the physicochemical
analysis:
Table 5. Physicochemical parameters of the treatment with the highest
acceptance by the sensory panel.
Physicochemical analysis of the best-scoring carbonated beverage
treatment
Armijos, 2022
Results of the microbiological analysis of the best-scoring
treatment of the kiwi, achotillo and moringa carbonated
beverage.
The results of the microbiological analyses performed on treatment 2
of the kiwi, achotillo and moringa carbonated beverage indicate that
they are within the microbiological parameters established by NTE
INEN 1101:2008 for carbonated beverages. Table 6 shows the results
of the microbiological quality analysis of the carbonated beverage:
Table 6. Results of microbiological analysis of the treatment with the
highest acceptance by the sensory panel.
Parameters
Results
Acidity
0.27%
Brix
pH
Volume CO2
6.2
4.3
2.6
July - September vol. 1. Num. 18 - 2023
45
Microbiological analysis results
Armijos, 2022
For the present study, the vitamin C content and amino acid profile of
a carbonated beverage with kiwi, achotillo and moringa were
determined, for which three different treatments were formulated with
different percentages as indicated in previous sections (T1: 25% kiwi,
45% achotillo, 0.1% moringa, 0.25% monkfruit and 0.25% sodium
benzoate).1% moringa, 0.25% monkfruit and 0.25% sodium benzoate)
T2: 20% kiwifruit, 50% achotillo, 0.1% moringa, 0.25% monkfruit and
0.25% sodium benzoate) T3: 15% kiwifruit, 55% achotillo, 0.1%
moringa, 0.25% monkfruit and 0.25% sodium benzoate). According to
the results obtained from the sensory panel, the most acceptable
treatment in terms of color, odor and flavor attributes was treatment 2,
which was analyzed for vitamin C content, amino acid profile,
physicochemical analysis (acidity, pH, °brix and volume of CO )
2
and
microbiological analysis (total coliforms, mesophiles, molds and
yeasts). In a study conducted by Gonzaga (2017), where he conducted
sensory analysis of a carbonated beverage made from naranjilla pulp,
the formulation of the beverage made up of 25% naranjilla pulp and
10% sweetener obtained greater acceptance; this formulation had a
greater amount of pulp extract, which allowed it to maintain the
characteristic flavor, color and smell of the fruit; however, the panelists
recommended reducing the intensity of the sweet flavor. Based on the
above, it can be indicated that in the carbonated beverage proposed with
kiwi, achotillo and moringa, a value of 2% was considered for the
sweetener based on the juice of the fruits that were added, so that it
would not be affected in terms of the sweet flavor and thus could
highlight a characteristic flavor of the fruits used in the beverage.
Rodriguez (2020) evaluated the organoleptic characteristics of a
beverage made from soy milk and kiwi, flavored with passion fruit. The
Requirements
Unit Results Test method
Total coliforms
Mesophilic
Molds and yeasts
NMP/ml <3 PEE.LASA.MB.01b;BAM
CAP.
4,ED.2017
CFU/g 3.0x10
4
BAM-FDA CAP.#3
2001
(Plate count)
CFU/g <10 INEN 1529-10 1998
(Plate count)
Vitamin C content and amino acid identification in carbonated beverage with kiwifruit (Actinidia
deliciosa), ACHOTILLO (Nephelium lappaceum) and MORINGA (Moringa oleifera)
46
best qualified treatment of this beverage was treatment 4 made with
40% soy and 40% kiwi, while the remaining treatments showed no
significant difference between them, with measurements well below the
winning treatment. Similar results were shown in the sensory evaluation
of the kiwi, achotillo and moringa carbonated beverage, where it was
shown that the treatment with the highest sensory mean was treatment
2, but in this case it did not show a significant difference with treatment
1, for which the highest mean corresponding to T2 was chosen.
The analysis to determine the vitamin C content of treatment 2, chosen
by the sensory panel for being the highest scoring, resulted in a value
of 212.39 mg/kg (21.24 mg/100g), a value higher than the vitamin C
content obtained by Maldonado and Moncayo (2012), in their
carbonated passion fruit drink where they recorded a vitamin C value
of 10.02 mg/100g of vitamin C, this result is surpassed by the proposed
carbonated drink of kiwi, achotillo and moringa because the matrices
used have a high vitamin C content, highlighting for example 70
mg/100 g is the vitamin C content of achotillo, 93 mg/100 g is that of
kiwi and 70 mg/100 g in moringa, all these matrices exceed the fruit
used by Maldonado and Moncayo (2012), which contains 30 mg/100 g
of this vitamin. On the other hand, in a study conducted by Cantillo
(2020), where he elaborated nectar based on achotillo and apple
enriched with alfalfa as a nutritional contribution, he evaluated the
vitamin C content by the method of volumetric titration to several
treatments in which the control treatment consisting of 50% achotillo
and 50% apple obtained a higher vitamin C content which was
26.25mg/100 ml, followed by the treatment consisting of alfalfa 2.5%,
achotillo 40% and apple 57.5% with a vitamin C content of 24.13
mg/100 ml and the lowest value was the treatment made up of 5%
alfalfa, 50% achotillo and 45% apple which was 18.25/100 ml,
resembling these vitamin C contents with that of the present project
under study which includes one of the fruits used (achotillo) by the
authors mentioned above, this being a carbonated beverage. It is
important to highlight that pasteurization is a treatment that affects the
loss of vitamin C as confirmed by Villareal, Mejía, Osorio, and Ceron
(2013), who analyzed the effect of pasteurization on sensory
characteristics and vitamin C content in fruit juice, which were tree
tomato juice, costeño mango juice, valencia orange and castilla
blackberry, initially these juices had a vitamin C content of 6.4mg/100g,
7.2mg/100g, 55mg/100g and 2.4mg/100g, after being subjected to
July - September vol. 1. Num. 18 - 2023
47
different temperatures and pasteurization times for each juice,
corresponding as follows, blackberry juice T=80°C and t=120 s, mango
juice T=85°C and t=120 s, tree tomato juice T=80°C and t=90 s and
orange juice T=75°C and t=90 s, evidenced a loss of vitamin C in each
fruit juice, for tree tomato juice the loss was 87.72%, mango juice
89.82%, orange juice 99.43% and blackberry juice 84.67%. On the
other hand, Rodriguez (2007), elaborated and determined the stability
of an isotonic drink based on Kiwi and Guava added with conjugated
linoleic acid (CLA), where the fruits with peel were subjected to a steam
scalding at 80°C for 30 minutes, the analysis of vitamin C was carried
out by the spectrophotometric method, obtaining as a result a vitamin C
content of 41.This value is almost double that found in the carbonated
kiwi achotillo and moringa drink with a vitamin C content of 21.24
mg/100 g. It is important to note that guava has 3 times more vitamin C
than kiwifruit and almost 4 times more than achotillo, and the heat
treatment applied to the isotonic beverage influences the vitamin C
value to be higher than that found in the carbonated kiwifruit achotillo
and moringa beverage, which was pasteurized at 75°C for 25 minutes.
The results for the amino acid profile of the kiwi achotillo and moringa
carbonated beverage of treatment 2 chosen as the most acceptable by
the sensory panel, recorded the following results; Aspartic Acid 0.18
g/100 g (1.8mg/g sample), Glutamic Acid 0.35 g/100 g (3.5 mg/g
sample), Serine 0.12 g/100g (1.2 mg/g sample), Threonine 0.12 g/100g
(1.2 mg/g sample), Glycine 0.16 g/100 g (1.6 mg/g sample), Arginine
0.12 g/100 g (1.2 mg/g sample), Tyrosine 0.75g/100 g (7.5 mg/g
sample), Valine 0.09 g/100 g (0.9 mg/g sample), Methionine 0.04 g/100
g (0.4 mg/g sample), Phenyl alanine 0.12 g/100 g(1.2 mg/g sample),
Isoleucine 0.09 g/100 g (0.9 mg/g sample), Leucine 0.13 g/100 g (1.3
mg/g sample), Lysine 0.05 g/100 g (0.5 mg/g sample), with total
essential amino acids (lysine, leucine, threonine, isoleucine,
methionine, valine, phenylalanine) of 0.64 g/100 g except for Histidine
and Alanine, results that are well below that evidenced by Santos
(2019), who performed a characterization of a Tea by using moringa
leaves which determined the amino acid profile in moringa leaves
dehydrated at different temperatures 35, 45 and 55°C characterizing the
amino acid profile by the HPLC method where the highest content of
essential amino acids was identified in the treatment at 55°C obtaining
as a result 16.It is important to highlight that the author mentions that
the heat applied to the fresh moringa leaves to dehydrate them
influenced the concentration of amino acids, because there was a greater
loss of water in the leaves when the temperature of 55°C was applied,
Vitamin C content and amino acid identification in carbonated beverage with kiwifruit (Actinidia
deliciosa), ACHOTILLO (Nephelium lappaceum) and MORINGA (Moringa oleifera)
48
so that at this temperature the concentration of amino acids was not high
enough.
In another study conducted by Vendrell (2021), on the protein and
antioxidant enrichment of cookies with moringa dried leaves powder,
where he added moringa powder to wheat flour in different proportions
called G1 and G10, G1 consisted of 1% moringa powder and 53%
wheat flour while G10 consisted of 10% moringa powder and 44%
wheat flour in this study determined the amino acid profile of the cookie
made with these formulations using the gas chromatography method,
the highest results of amino acids were given in the formulation G10
which were; for Isoleucine 0.02 g/100 g sample, Aspartic Acid 0.33
g/100 g sample, Glutamic Acid 0.45 g/100 g sample, Serine 0.18 g/100g
sample, Threonine 0.1 g/100g sample, Proline 0.015g/100 g sample,
Asparagine 0.03 g/100 g sample, Hydroxyproline 0.01 mg/100 g
sample, Tyrosine 0.02 g/100 g sample, Methionine 0.09 g/100 g sample,
Phenylalanine 0.02 g/100 g sample, α-aminoadipic acid 0.6 g/100 g
sample, as can be evidenced the results only contain 3 of the essential
amino acids ( Isoleucine 0.02 g/100 g sample , Methionine 0.09 g/100
g sample and Phenylalanine 0.02 g/100 g of sample), these quantities
are lower than the essential amino acids found in the carbonated kiwi,
achotillo and moringa beverage, of which Isoleucine with 0.09 g/100 g
and Phenylalanine with 0.12 g/100 g are found in greater proportion.
This loss of essential amino acids in the case of the cookie is due to the
high baking temperature (180 ºC) applied for the elaboration of the
cookie, as stated by the author Vendrell (2021).
The results obtained for the physicochemical parameters of the kiwi
achotillo and moringa beverage of treatment T2 selected as the most
acceptable by the sensory panel were 6.2 °brix, 4.3 pH, titratable acidity
0.27% and CO2 volume of 2.6 /L, which are within the range
established by the INEN (2008) standard for low-calorie carbonated
beverages, however, in the physicochemical results obtained by
Gonzaga (2017), where he elaborated a carbonated beverage with
naranjilla pulp presented 10°brix, pH 3.5, titratable acidity 0.55% and
CO2 volume of 2.5 /L, this beverage reflects higher values in terms of
acidity and pH, this is due to the fact that naranjilla has an acidity of
2.56%. Gonzaga (2017)being more acidic than kiwi with 1.18% Godoy
and Dome (2013), and achotillo with 0.30% acidity Avendaño-Arrazate
et al., (2017), fruits that were occupied for the elaboration of the
carbonated beverage of the present research.
July - September vol. 1. Num. 18 - 2023
49
Finally, microbiological parameters were evaluated for treatment 2,
based on the INEN (2008) standard for carbonated beverages, showing
results for total coliforms < 3 (Absence), Mesophiles < 1/d (Absence),
molds and yeasts < 10, showing that all these values are in accordance
with the specifications established by the INEN 1101 standard:2008 for
carbonated beverages, it should be mentioned the importance of
performing microbiological analyses since they determine the safety of
the process and can affect the shelf life and sensory parameters of the
beverage.
4. Conclusions
According to the sensory analysis carried out on the carbonated
beverage made with kiwi (15%), achotillo (25%) and moringa (0.1%),
treatment 2 was chosen as it presented the greatest acceptance by the
sensory panel with respect to the attributes of color, odor and flavor,
evaluated with the help of the infostad program, where it was
determined through the analysis of variance that treatment 2, although
it did not present a significant difference with treatment 1, was chosen
as it showed the highest mean among the three treatments carried out.
From the results obtained by the laboratory with respect to vitamin C
and the amino acid profile of treatment 2 of the carbonated beverage,
212.39 mg/kg (21.24 mg/100 g) of vitamin C content was obtained, this
amount would represent approximately 20% of the recommended daily
value of vitamin C indicated as a voluntary declaration for nutrients in
INEN 1334-2 Labeling of Food Products for Human Consumption Part
2: Nutritional Labeling. Requirements (NTE INEN 1334-2, 2011).
In relation to the amino acid profile, it could be evidenced that the
beverage presents a total of 2.29 AAg/100 gram of sample, being able
to highlight this presence of nutrients when compared with other
carbonated beverages in the market. It should be emphasized that for
this research only 0.1% of moringa was used, which is a good source of
amino acids, but for formulation purposes the amount added was low
due to its intense flavor and aroma, which is not accustomed to the
palate of consumers, which altered the sensory quality of the proposed
beverage.
The results of the physicochemical parameters for the kiwi, achotillo
and moringa carbonated beverage of treatment 2 were 6.2 ° Brix, 4.3
pH, titratable acidity 0.27% and CO2 volume of 2.6 /L. These results
show that they are within the ranges established by the INEN 2008
standard for carbonated beverages. With respect to the microbiological
results for mesophilic aerobes, total coliforms, molds and yeasts, the
Vitamin C content and amino acid identification in carbonated beverage with kiwifruit (Actinidia
deliciosa), ACHOTILLO (Nephelium lappaceum) and MORINGA (Moringa oleifera)
50
carbonated beverage complies with the parameters required by the NTE
INEN 2008 standard.
References
Cantillo, G. N. (July 21, 2020). AGRICULTURAL INFORMATION CENTER.
Retrieved from ELABORATION OF NECTAR BASED ON
ACHOTILLO (Nephelium lappaceum) AND APPLE (Malus
domestica) ENRICHED WITH ALFALFA (Medicago sativa) AS
NUTRITIONAL SUPPLY:
https://cia.uagraria.edu.ec/Archivos/CANTILLO%20HOLGUIN%20
GENESIS%20NATHALY.pdf
Carr, A. C., and Maggini, S. (2017). Vitamin C and Immune Function.
https://doi.org/10.3390/nu9111211
Carr, and Frei (1999). Toward a new recommended dietary allowance
for vitamin C based on antioxidant and health effects in humans1-
3. Linus Pauling Institute.
Carvallo, P., Carvallo, E., Barbosa-Da-Silva, S., Carlos, ;, Mandarim-
De-Lacerda, A., Alfonso Hernandez, ;, and Del Sol, M. (2019).
Metabolic Effects of Excessive Fructose Consumption Added
Metabolic Effects of Excessive Fructose Consumption Added. In
Int. J. Morphol (Vol. 37, Issue 3).
Castillo-Portela, Villar-Delgado, Montano-Martínez, Pérez-Alfocea,
Sánchez-Bravo, and Acosta-Echeverría (2011). ICIDCA. Sobre
los Derivados de la Caña de Azúcar. ICIDCA.
https://www.redalyc.org/pdf/2231/223122251008.pdf
Cedaro, Cava, L., and Sgroppo (2015). (PDF) Analysis of vitamin C
content and labeling of analcoholic beverages commonly offered
in the city of Resistencia (Chaco, Argentina). La Alimentacion
Latinoamericana.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/330485872_Analisis_d
el_contenido_de_vitamina_C_y_rotulado_de_bebidas_analcoholi
cas_de_oferta_habitual_en_la_ciudad_de_Resistencia_Chaco_Ar
gentina.
Fang (2017). FACULTY OF PHARMACY UNIVERSIDAD
COMPLUTENSE FIN DE GRADUATE WORK Analytical
methods for the determination of vitamin C in foods
[UNIVERSIDAD COMPLUTENSE].
http://147.96.70.122/Web/TFG/TFG/Memoria/ZHONGWEI
FANG.pdf.
July - September vol. 1. Num. 18 - 2023
51
FAO. (2019). Five steps we all need to take to ensure food safety |
Stories from FAO | Food and Agriculture Organization of the
United Nations. http://www.fao.org/fao-
stories/article/es/c/1194120/
Gaona-Gonzeaga, M. E. D., Brito Grandes Beatriz, S. C. A., and Viera
Arroyo William (2019). Exploitation of naranjilla (Solanum
quitoense Lam.) variety INIAP Quitoense-2009 to obtain a
carbonated beverage. 9.
https://www.redalyc.org/jatsRepo/5722/572262062009/57226206
2009.pdf
Godoy, C., and Dome, C. (2013). Relationship between physiological
maturity and commercial maturity of 'Hayward' kiwifruit fruits
produced in southeastern Buenos Aires province (Argentina). Journal
of the Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, 311-325.
Gonzaga, J. P. G. (2017). UNIVERSIDAD CENTRAL DEL ECUADOR
FACULTY OF CHEMICAL ENGINEERING CHEMICAL
ENGINEERING CAREER ELABORATION OF A NATURAL
CARBONATED BEVERAGE FROM THE NATURAL PULP OF
NARANJILLA (SOLANUM QUITOENSE) [UNIVERSIDAD
CENTRAL DEL ECUADOR].
http://www.dspace.uce.edu.ec/bitstream/25000/13589/1/T-UCE-
0017-0077-2017.pdf
INEN, (2006). https://www.normalizacion.gob.ec/buzon/normas/1529-
5.pdf
INEN (2013). Standardization Service.
https://www.normalizacion.gob.ec/buzon/normas/nte_inen_1529-
10-1.pdf
INEN (09 of 10 of 2008). Standardization . Retrieved from Normalizacion :
https://www.normalizacion.gob.ec/buzon/normas/1101.pdf
NTE INEN 1334-2. (2011). Labeling of food products for human
consumption. Part 2. Nutritional labeling requirements. Retrieved
from NORMA
INEN:https://www.controlsanitario.gob.ec/wpcontent/uploads/downl
oads2016/12/NTE-INEN-1334-2-Rotulado-de-Productos-
Alimenticios-para consumo-Humano-parte-2.pdf
Llanes (2015). Functional foods and biotechnology. Colom.Biotecnol.
Maersk, M., Belza, A., Stødkilde-Jørgensen, H., Ringgaard, S.,
Chabanova, E., Thomsen, H., Pedersen, S. B., Astrup, A., and
Richelsen, B. (2012). Sucrose-sweetened beverages increase fat
storage in the liver, muscle, and visceral fat depot: a 6-mo
randomized intervention study 1-3.
https://doi.org/10.3945/ajcn.111.022533
Maldonado, and Moncayo (2012). Elaboration of a passion fruit
Vitamin C content and amino acid identification in carbonated beverage with kiwifruit (Actinidia
deliciosa), ACHOTILLO (Nephelium lappaceum) and MORINGA (Moringa oleifera)
52
carbonated beverage. file:///C:/Users/user/Downloads/105571
(4).pdf.
McEvily, A. J., Iyengar, R., and Gross, A. T. (1992). Inhibition of
Polyphenol Oxidase by Phenolic Compounds (pp. 318-325).
https://doi.org/10.1021/bk-1992-0506.ch025.
Miranda, et al. (2013). Liquid Chromatography (HPLC).
https://www.ucm.es/data/cont/docs/650-2013-12-02-gases
liquids.pdf.
Rodriguez. (2020). UNIVERSIDAD AGRARIA DEL ECUADOR
FACULTAD DE CIENCIAS AGRARIAS DETERMINATION OF
THE PRESENCE OF ANTIOXIDANTS IN A BEVERAGE MADE
WITH SOYBEAN (Glycine max) AND KIWI (Actinidia deliciosa),
FLAVORED WITH MARACUYÁ EXPERIMENTAL WORK.
Rubio-Sanz (2020). View of NUTRITIONAL COMPARATIVE OF THE
CULTIVATION OF Moringa oleifera IN SPAIN | Science and
Technology. https://doi.org/:
https://doi.org/10.18779/cyt.v13i2.388
Sanchinelli, P. K. (2004). Protein and amino acid content and generation of sensory
descriptors of stems, leaves and flowers of Moringa oleifera Lamark
(Moringaceae) grown in Guatemala. San Carlos University of Guatemala. A.
Santillan. (2013). Nutritional and medicinal benefits of moringa -
Ciencia UNAM. Nutritional and Medicinal Benefits of Moringa.
http://ciencia.unam.mx/leer/261/Beneficios_nutritivos_y_medici
nales_de_la_moringa
Santos, K. M. (2019). DSpace ESPOCH. Retrieved from "ELABORATION
AND CHARACTERIZATION OF A TEA THROUGH THE USE
OF MORINGA (Moringa oleifera) LEAVES":
http://dspace.espoch.edu.ec/bitstream/123456789/13478/1/27T0416.
pdf
Solutions, A. H. (2021). Amino acids: MedlinePlus medical
encyclopedia. MedilinePlus.
https://medlineplus.gov/spanish/ency/article/002222.htm
Valverde (2018). PRODUCTION OF SUGAR-SWEETENED
BEVERAGES FROM THE ORGANIC LAW FOR THE BALANCE
OF PUBLIC FINANCES. INSTITUTO DE ALTOS ESTUDIOS
NACIONALES UNIVERSIDAD DE POSTGRADO DEL
ESTADO.
Vendrell, H. (July 10, 2021). riunet. Retrieved from Protein and antioxidant
enrichment of moringa and sensory acceptability:
https://riunet.upv.es/bitstream/handle/10251/171147/Vendrell%20-
%20Enriquecimiento%20proteico%20y%20antioxidante%20de%20
July - September vol. 1. Num. 18 - 2023
53
galletas%20con%20polvo%20de%20hojas%20secas%20de%20mori
n....pdf?sequence=4
Villareal, Y., Mejía, D. F., Osorio, O., and Ceron, C. F. (April 23, 2013).
Scielo. Retrieved from EFFECT OF PASTEURIZATION ON
SENSORY CHARACTERISTICS AND VITAMIN C CONTENT
IN FRUIT JUICES:
http://www.scielo.org.co/pdf/bsaa/v11n2/v11n2a08.pdf